The Old Fashioned candle smells like a well-made glass of its namesake. The main scent is bright and citrus-y with just the right amount of cherry mixed in and the darker "something" of the bitters scent to keep it grounded and not too flashy and in your face.
The scent is interesting but comfortable and invites you to relax for a while. It's my favorite candle to burn in the evening when I'm in my comfy reading chair with a book and no plans for tomorrow.